£0.00 0

Cart

No products in the cart.

Continue shopping

The butchr's block

Choosing the Right Barbecue: Gas, Charcoal, Pellet, Kamado, or Electric?

Selecting the right barbecue grill is pivotal for achieving the cooking results you desire. The market offers a variety of options—gas, charcoal, pellet, kamado, and electric—each tailored to specific needs, flavour profiles, and levels of convenience. Understanding the unique features of each type will help you make an informed choice. Let’s explore their key characteristics.

Gas Barbecues

Gas barbecues are widely favoured for their ease of use and rapid heat-up times. They’re ideal for those who value convenience without sacrificing performance.

Pros:

  • Effortless Start-Up: Gas grills ignite quickly, reaching optimal temperatures in minutes.
  • Temperature Precision: Built-in controls allow fine-tuned adjustments, ensuring even cooking across a range of dishes.
  • Ease of Cleaning: The absence of ash simplifies clean-up compared to charcoal models.
  • Versatility: Many include additional features such as side burners and rotisseries.

Cons:

  • Mild Flavour: While efficient, gas grills lack the smoky essence produced by other fuel types.
  • Initial Investment: High-quality gas grills can be expensive, although operating costs are moderate.
  • Limited Portability: Models tied to natural gas lines restrict mobility.

Suggested Brands:

  • Weber (Genesis Series)
  • Napoleon (Prestige Pro Series)
  • Broil King (Regal Series)

Steve’s Opinion: A gas grill is always useful to have, quick to get up and running, when you consider the weather in this country it may be the best choice.


Charcoal Barbecues

For purists seeking authentic barbecue flavour, charcoal grills are the gold standard. They run on briquettes or lump charcoal, delivering unmatched smokiness.

Pros:

  • Enhanced Flavour: The smoke from burning coals imparts a rich, distinctive taste.
  • High Heat: Ideal for searing and achieving char marks on steaks etc.
  • Cost-Effective Options: Basic models are affordable and easy to find.

Cons:

  • Time-Intensive: Lighting and preparing coals requires patience and practice.
  • Manual Temperature Control: Adjusting heat involves managing coals and air vents.
  • Clean-Up Challenges: Ash and residue require careful disposal.

Suggested Brands:

  • Weber (Original Kettle)
  • Big Green Egg (MiniMax)
  • Char-Griller (Outlaw Series)

Steve’s Opinion: If you are just starting out on your BBQ journey there nothing better than a simple Weber Kettle. less than £100, You can cook anything on it and you can develop yours skills first before you upgrade


Pellet Grills

Pellet grills bridge the gap between convenience and flavour. Using compressed wood pellets as fuel, these grills offer precision and versatility.

Pros:

  • Consistent Flavour: Wood pellets infuse food with deep, smoky undertones.
  • Versatility: Suitable for smoking, roasting, grilling, and even baking.
  • Automated Temperature Control: Digital settings simplify operation, maintaining consistent heat levels.

Cons:

  • Expense: Both initial purchase and ongoing pellet costs are higher than other options.
  • Reliance on Electricity: Operation requires a power source, limiting portability.
  • Maintenance Requirements: Frequent cleaning is necessary to prevent clogging.

Suggested Brands:

  • Traeger (Pro Series)
  • Pit Boss (Sportsman Series)
  • Green Mountain Grills (Daniel Boone Prime)
  • Weber Smokefire

Steve’s Opinion: I love my pellet grills, when you are cooking commercially I love the consistency they give me and their so simple to use. Set it and leave it. Great for smoking, not so good for searing a steak.


Kamado Grills

Kamado grills, with their ceramic construction and versatile functionality, are a standout choice for serious barbecue enthusiasts. These grills excel at both high-heat grilling and low-and-slow smoking.

Pros:

  • Exceptional Heat Retention: The ceramic body ensures steady, uniform heat for long durations.
  • Culinary Versatility: Perfect for grilling, smoking, and baking pizzas or bread.
  • Flavour Depth: Lumpwood charcoal enhances the natural smokiness of foods.
  • Durability: Engineered to endure extreme conditions and last for years.

Cons:

  • High Cost: Premium quality comes at a price.
  • Heavy and Stationary: Their weight makes them less portable.
  • Steep Learning Curve: Mastering airflow adjustments for temperature control requires experience.

Suggested Brands:

  • Big Green Egg (Large)
  • Kamado Joe (Classic II)
  • Char-Griller (Akorn Kamado)

Steve’s Opinion: Kamado grills are pretty much the gold standard when it comes to charcoal grills, they are expensive though. Build your skill set before investing in one.


Electric Grills

Electric grills are tailored for convenience and indoor use, making them an excellent option for those with limited outdoor space.

Pros:

  • Ease of Use: Simply plug in, set the temperature, and begin cooking.
  • Year-Round Usability: Many models are designed for indoor use, offering flexibility regardless of weather.
  • Compact Design: Perfect for small patios or balconies.

Cons:

  • Flavour Limitations: Without open flames, the smoky barbecue essence is absent.
  • Heat Constraints: These grills often lack the capacity for high-temperature searing.
  • Electric Dependency: Mobility is restricted to areas with power access.

Suggested Brands:

  • George Foreman (Indoor/Outdoor Grill)
  • Weber (Q Series)
  • Cuisinart (Griddler Elite)

Steve’s Opinion: I wouldn’t bother 🙂


Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Grill

If you would like to have an unbiased chat about what may be best for you, come into the shop and have a chat.

Selecting the ideal barbecue requires evaluating several key factors:

1. Flavour Profile:

  • For smoky, robust flavours, consider charcoal, pellet, or kamado grills.
  • If lighter flavours are acceptable, gas or electric models suffice.

2. Convenience:

  • Opt for gas or electric grills for quick and simple operation.
  • Choose charcoal, pellet, or kamado grills if you prefer a hands-on approach.

3. Budget:

  • Basic charcoal grills are budget-friendly.
  • Gas, pellet, and kamado grills involve higher initial costs but often include advanced features.

4. Cooking Style:

  • Pellet and kamado grills are ideal for smoking.
  • For searing, consider charcoal or gas.
  • Gas grills are versatile for general-purpose use.

5. Space and Mobility:

  • Electric grills are suited for compact spaces.
  • Charcoal grills are highly portable for outdoor adventures.
  • Kamado, gas, and pellet grills are better for permanent setups.

Conclusion

The best barbecue depends on your priorities, whether that’s convenience, flavour, or versatility. Gas grills offer quick, precise cooking; charcoal grills deliver unbeatable smoky flavours; pellet grills combine ease with culinary diversity; kamado grills bring unmatched heat retention and flexibility; and electric grills provide straightforward solutions for smaller spaces. By assessing your needs and preferences, you’ll find the perfect grill to elevate your barbecue experience.

Happy grilling!

CLICK & COLLECT

Local & National delivery available

masters of meat

2 St. Brides Court

Mid Devon Business Park

Willand, Cullompton

Devon. EX15 2FN

01884 824070

Shop Hours

Monday
CLOSED
Tuesday
7.30 AM - 4.00 PM
Wednesday
7.30 AM - 4.00 PM
Thursday
7.30 AM - 4.00 PM
Friday
7.30 AM - 4.00 PM
Saturday
7.30 AM - 2.00 PM
Sunday
CLOSED

Subscribe & Save

Sign up to our newsletter to receive vouchers, discounts, news and recipes etc
Get a 10% Discount on your first order as a thank you from us when you sign up
Newsletter Form (#3)

Save 10% when you subscribe to our newsletter

Receive news, recipes and special offers in your inbox
Newsletter Form (#3)

Suggested Roasting Joint Sizes

Here's a handy chart to help determine the right portion sizes for meat joints based on appetite size:

Appetite SizeBoneless Meat (g per head)Bone-in Meat (g per head)
Small Appetite125–150 g200–250 g
Medium Appetite150–200 g250–300 g
Large Appetite200–250 g300–350 g
Extra Large Appetite250–300 g350–400 g

Notes:

  • Boneless Meat: Includes lean cuts like beef topside, pork loin, or chicken breast.
  • Bone-in Meat: Includes cuts like leg of lamb, rib roast, or chicken thighs.

These portions are for the main course. If the meat is part of a larger meal with substantial sides, you could reduce the quantities slightly. For feasts or special occasions where people may indulge, consider the higher end of the range.

login to your butchr. account

Login
Register an Account